Can Sindh break away from Pakistan?

On November 17, Pakistan People’s Party (PPP) chairman Bilawal Bhutto Zardari warned against any forced division of Sindh. “If the province is divided by force, society will be divided, it will lead to enmity, ordinary people will take up arms, and the bloodshed will not be limited to a single death,” he said. The remarks came while addressing a Meet the Press programme at the Karachi Press Club.

Bilawal said the PPP would oppose any “unconstitutional move” to divide the province. He maintained that any such decision must follow constitutional and democratic procedures and reflect the wishes of the people.

On the same day, Shafi Muhammad Burfat, chairman of the Jeay Sindh Muttahida Mahaz (JSMM), called for an independent 'Sindhudesh', in a statement shared on X. Declaring that “Sindh's continuation within Pakistan is a death warrant against the existence of the Sindhi nation,” Burfat argued that Sindh's inclusion within Pakistan threatened its historical identity and territorial unity.

He accused the country's establishment of exploiting the province's natural resources and undermining its political and cultural autonomy. Burfat's demand raises a larger question about the history of Sindhi separatism and whether the idea of an independent Sindhudesh has any realistic prospects.

The two statements came amid a debate over Pakistan's provincial structure. Interior Minister Mohsin Naqvi has proposed creating new administrative units. On November 12, he suggested holding a referendum to establish public opinion on the creation of new provinces or administrative units. Defence Minister Khawaja Asif has supported the idea of expanding Pakistan's existing four-province structure.

The debate is linked to a proposed 28th Constitutional Amendment that could increase Pakistan's four provinces to 12, which includes dividing Sindh. However, Article 239(4) requires a two-thirds majority in the Sindh Assembly to alter the province's boundaries. The PPP has opposed the proposal, bringing Sindh's territorial future into the centre of Pakistan's political debate.

Countering the PPP’s opposition, the Muttahida Qaumi Movement-Pakistan (MQM-P) has renewed its demand for new administrative units in Sindh, arguing that urban centres such as Karachi need greater control over local resources and governance.

Sindhi nationalism predates the creation of Pakistan. One of its early political expressions was the campaign to separate Sindh from the Bombay Presidency under British rule. Sindh became a separate province in 1936. The demand at the time was for provincial autonomy and a distinct political identity.

Partition in 1947 led to the arrival of large numbers of Muslim migrants from India, particularly in urban centres, altered Sindh's population and social structure. Karachi was separated from Sindh in 1948 and made the federal capital territory. These developments, fuelled with growing concerns over the central government's influence, contributed to a sense of political and cultural marginalisation among sections of the Sindhi population.

The introduction of the ‘One Unit scheme’ in 1955 merged the provinces and princely states of West Pakistan into a single administrative unit. Sindhi nationalists opposed the move, arguing that it weakened the province's identity and autonomy. The scheme remained in place until 1970, when the provinces were restored.

Ghulam Murtaza Syed emerged as one of the central figures in this movement. He initially campaigned against centralisation and for Sindh's provincial rights. In 1971, the separation of East Pakistan and the creation of Bangladesh influenced his political thinking. In late 1973, G.M. Syed formally embraced the demand for an independent Sindh, known as ‘Sindhudesh’. He developed the idea through the Jeay Sindh Mahaz, which had earlier focused on provincial autonomy. The demand was based on the argument that Sindh had a distinct historical, linguistic and cultural identity that deserved political sovereignty.

After Syed's death in 1995, the broader Jeay Sindh movement fragmented into several organisations. Differences over political strategy, electoral participation and the use of violence contributed to the divisions. Some groups continued to pursue provincial autonomy through electoral politics, while others retained the demand for independence.

Shafi Burfat broke away from the Jeay Sindh Qaumi Mahaz in 2000 and formed the Jeay Sindh Muttahida Mahaz. The organisation advocates Sindh's separation from Pakistan and the creation of an independent Sindhudesh. Pakistan banned the JSMM in 2013 and declared it as an “terrorist organisation”. Burfat has since operated from exile in Germany and continued to raise the issue through international platforms. In a January 2026 report, Pakistan-based Dawn described the JSMM as one of several factions of the Sindhi nationalist movement, with Burfat leading the organisation from abroad.

An independent ‘Sindhudesh’ would broadly comprise the present territory of Pakistan's Sindh province — Karachi, Hyderabad, Sukkur and other major urban centres. Its geographical position would give it direct access to the Arabian Sea and an important place along regional maritime routes.

Sindh is Pakistan's second-largest provincial economy and has a population of around 55.7 million, according to the 2023 census. Karachi is the country's largest city and its principal financial and commercial centre. The province also contains Karachi Port and Port Qasim — two major gateways for Pakistan's maritime trade. Its economy includes manufacturing, agriculture, energy and other industries. The Thar coalfield also holds substantial coal reserves, while the Indus River supports its agricultural base.

An independent ‘Sindhudesh’ would therefore control important commercial infrastructure, energy resources and a strategic coastline. However, separation would raise difficult questions over the ownership of ports, national assets, water distribution, trade routes and the movement of people. The Indus River, which flows through several Pakistani provinces, would be a particularly sensitive issue.

Despite its historical roots, the possibility of ‘Sindhudesh’ emerging as an independent country remains remote under present circumstances. The separatist movement has not demonstrated the broad electoral support or mass mobilisation required to translate its demand into a viable political project. Its organisations remain divided, while several groups associated with the broader movement follow different approaches to autonomy and independence.

The Pakistani state is also unlikely to accept the separation of a province that contains its largest city, principal commercial centre and major ports. Any such development would create serious economic, political and security consequences for the country. The movement also lacks meaningful international recognition or established diplomatic backing for an independent state.

The emergence of an independent ‘Sindhudesh’ could also create a new strategic equation for India. Sindh shares a border with India and has direct access to the Arabian Sea. A new political entity in the region could become an important neighbour for New Delhi. India could potentially explore diplomatic recognition, trade, investment and development cooperation if an independent Sindh emerged through a credible political process.

Burfat has previously appealed to India to recognise a proposed ‘Sindhudesh’ government-in-exile and support the movement's independence demand. In a situation of Pakistan's fragmentation, India's economic and diplomatic engagement could influence the future relationship with a new Sindhi state. Such a development could also weaken Pakistan's economic and strategic position through the loss of Karachi and its major ports. These remain possibilities rather than indications of any current Indian policy.

For now, ‘Sindhudesh’ remains merely a separatist aspiration and far from an imminent political reality. The renewed debate over Pakistan’s provincial restructuring has brought Sindh's territorial identity back into focus. However, the movement faces significant obstacles before its demand for independence can become a viable prospect.

Comments

There are 0 comments for this article

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published.